Conscientiousness and Sales Performance

Conscientiousness, the Big Five trait for being organized, dependable and driven to achieve, is the most consistent personality predictor of job performance across occupations. In sales, its achievement-striving part has been linked to actual sales results more strongly than to manager ratings. But the effects are modest, many older estimates have since been revised down, and in Ontario a conscientiousness test is a personality test: it belongs after a conditional offer.

Why do owners care about conscientiousness?

Here's the fair part. Every owner knows the rep who closes a big deal and then forgets to send the paperwork. Or who's brilliant in front of a customer and hopeless at following up. Conscientiousness is the trait that covers the follow-up, the CRM notes and the tenth call on a Friday afternoon.

So it's no surprise owners want to hire for it. The research gives them some reason to.

What does the research say?

It's the steady one. In Barrick and Mount's (1991, p. 1) landmark meta-analysis of the Big Five and job performance, conscientiousness "showed consistent relations with all job performance criteria for all occupational groups." No other Big Five trait did that.

In sales, achievement matters most. A meta-analysis of predictors for salespeople looked at parts of the Big Five separately. Achievement, a component of conscientiousness, predicted objective sales results at .41, against .25 for supervisor ratings (Vinchur et al., 1998). That gap is interesting: the trait showed up more in the numbers than in the manager's opinion.

It isn't the strongest predictor. In the same sales meta-analysis, biodata (.52) and sales ability measures (.45) predicted supervisor ratings more strongly than achievement did (.25), and potency, a part of extraversion, came in at .28 for ratings and .26 for sales (Vinchur et al., 1998). Conscientiousness is one good signal among several, not a master key.

The numbers are probably lower than they look. The most recent large review of selection research argued that earlier meta-analyses over-corrected for range restriction, and found that the procedures that ranked high before mostly stayed high, but with mean validity estimates reduced by .10 to .20 points (Sackett et al., 2022). Vinchur's figures come from 1998, before that critique, so treat them as upper estimates. The same review put structured interviews at the top, at .42 (Sackett et al., 2022).

Can you have too much conscientiousness?

Possibly, and the evidence is more nuanced than the "too much of a good thing" headlines suggest.

Le et al. (2011) found curvilinear relationships between personality and performance, meaning the benefit levels off at the high end. But they also found high conscientiousness was more beneficial in high-complexity jobs than in low-complexity ones. Carter et al. (2014) also found a curvilinear link between conscientiousness and performance when they used a different way of scoring the test.

So the honest version is: very high conscientiousness may stop paying off in simpler jobs, but in complex roles, which describes a lot of technical and solution selling, more of it still tends to help.

Where does conscientiousness testing sit in Ontario?

A conscientiousness questionnaire is a personality test. The Ontario Human Rights Commission's guidance says tests that assess "psychological or personality profiles" of applicants "should never be administered before a conditional offer of employment, and even then should be approached with caution" (Ontario Human Rights Commission [OHRC], 2008, section IV-6).

In our own process, personality testing comes after the offer, and we use it for coaching and onboarding, not to decide who gets hired. Our cognitive testing comes after the offer too.

How to see conscientiousness before the offer

You don't need a questionnaire to see how organized and driven someone is.

  1. Ask about systems, not traits. "Walk me through how you managed your pipeline last quarter. What did you check every Monday?" Conscientious people have specific answers.

  2. Ask about a goal they set and hit. Achievement striving shows up in stories about targets, not in claims of being "driven."

  3. Watch the small things. Did they confirm the interview time? Send what they said they'd send? Prepare for the role play? See how to run a sales role-play interview.

  4. Check the track record. Whether their results held up across years and employers says a lot. Our post on whether past sales success predicts success at your company covers what transfers.

  5. Ask references about follow-through. "Did they do what they said they'd do, without being chased?"

If you want a resilience angle too, our post on whether you can test a salesperson for resilience explains why grit mostly re-measures this same trait.

Two things that are both true

We'll own this one for HR: we sometimes hire the most charming candidate in the room and then spend a year managing their follow-up. Conscientiousness doesn't interview as well as charm does.

Conscientiousness is one of the most dependable personality signals in hiring research, and it shows up in real sales numbers. And it's still a modest predictor, better seen through what a candidate has done than through a questionnaire, which in Ontario belongs after the offer anyway. For owners in Guelph and across Ontario, look for the systems behind the results.

In short

Conscientiousness related to job performance across all occupational groups (Barrick & Mount, 1991), and in sales its achievement part predicted objective sales at .41 against .25 for ratings (Vinchur et al., 1998). Older figures like these may run high: a 2022 review cut the top methods' validity estimates by .10 to .20 and put structured interviews on top at .42 (Sackett et al., 2022). Very high conscientiousness can level off, but it was more helpful in complex jobs (Le et al., 2011). In Ontario, personality tests should never come before a conditional offer (OHRC, 2008).

Key takeaways

  • Conscientiousness "showed consistent relations with all job performance criteria for all occupational groups" (Barrick & Mount, 1991, p. 1).

  • Achievement, part of conscientiousness, predicted objective sales at .41 and supervisor ratings at .25 in a sales meta-analysis (Vinchur et al., 1998).

  • Biodata (.52) and sales ability measures (.45) predicted supervisor ratings more strongly than achievement (.25) (Vinchur et al., 1998).

  • The top-ranked selection methods had their validity estimates cut by .10 to .20 in 2022 (Sackett et al., 2022).

  • High conscientiousness was more beneficial in high-complexity jobs than low-complexity ones (Le et al., 2011).

  • Ontario's Human Rights Commission says personality tests should never be given before a conditional offer (OHRC, 2008).

Frequently asked questions

Does conscientiousness predict sales performance?

Yes, modestly. Its achievement part predicted objective sales at .41 in a 1998 sales meta-analysis (Vinchur et al., 1998), though later research suggests older estimates like this run high (Sackett et al., 2022).

Is conscientiousness the best predictor for salespeople?

It's the most consistent Big Five trait across jobs (Barrick & Mount, 1991), but other measures predicted sales ratings more strongly (Vinchur et al., 1998), and structured interviews top the revised rankings (Sackett et al., 2022).

Can a salesperson be too conscientious?

Some studies find benefits level off at very high levels (Carter et al., 2014; Le et al., 2011), but high conscientiousness was more beneficial in complex jobs (Le et al., 2011).

Can I test candidates for conscientiousness before the offer in Ontario?

A conscientiousness test is a personality test, and the Ontario Human Rights Commission says those should never be given before a conditional offer (OHRC, 2008). This is general information, not legal advice; confirm with employment counsel.

Work with us

Down to your last few candidates? Our Final Candidate Review tests your finalists against your own best people before you make the offer. If it doesn't help, you don't pay.

This post is general information, not legal advice. Confirm employment decisions with employment counsel.

References

  • Barrick, M. R., & Mount, M. K. (1991). The Big Five personality dimensions and job performance: A meta-analysis. Personnel Psychology, 44(1), 1-26. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1744-6570.1991.tb00688.x

  • Carter, N. T., Dalal, D. K., Boyce, A. S., O'Connell, M. S., Kung, M.-C., & Delgado, K. M. (2014). Uncovering curvilinear relationships between conscientiousness and job performance: How theoretically appropriate measurement makes an empirical difference. Journal of Applied Psychology, 99(4), 564-586. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0034688

  • Le, H., Oh, I.-S., Robbins, S. B., Ilies, R., Holland, E., & Westrick, P. (2011). Too much of a good thing: Curvilinear relationships between personality traits and job performance. Journal of Applied Psychology, 96(1), 113-133. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0021016

  • Ontario Human Rights Commission. (2008). Human rights at work 2008 (3rd ed.), section IV-6: Requesting job-related sensitive information. https://www.ohrc.on.ca/en/iv-human-rights-issues-all-stages-employment/6-requesting-job-related-sensitive-information

  • Sackett, P. R., Zhang, C., Berry, C. M., & Lievens, F. (2022). Revisiting meta-analytic estimates of validity in personnel selection: Addressing systematic overcorrection for restriction of range. Journal of Applied Psychology, 107(11), 2040-2068. https://doi.org/10.1037/apl0000994

  • Vinchur, A. J., Schippmann, J. S., Switzer, F. S., & Roth, P. L. (1998). A meta-analytic review of predictors of job performance for salespeople. Journal of Applied Psychology, 83(4), 586-597. https://doi.org/10.1037/0021-9010.83.4.586

Next
Next

Staffing Agency vs Search Firm for a Sales Hire: An Honest Comparison