Emotional Intelligence Tests for Salespeople: What the Evidence Says

Emotional intelligence tests are a mixed bag for sales hiring. Ability-based tests that measure how well someone reads and manages emotions predict performance better in jobs with heavy emotional demands, like many sales roles, but the popular self-report EQ questionnaires mostly re-measure personality and confidence you could assess other ways. Either kind is a psychometric test, and in our process those come after the offer. Before the offer, the better look at emotional skill is watching how a candidate handles a buyer.

Why does EQ sound so right for sales?

Here's the fair part. Selling is emotional work. Reading a buyer who's nervous about a decision, staying steady after the third "no" of the morning, noticing that the CFO went quiet when you mentioned price. The best salespeople we've seen are good at exactly this.

So "hire for emotional intelligence" sounds like common sense. The research says the idea isn't wrong. It's the tests that need a closer look.

Is there more than one kind of EQ test?

Yes, and the difference matters more than anything else in this post.

  • Ability EI tests ask people to solve emotional problems, like identifying the emotion in a face or picking the best way to handle a tense situation. There are right and wrong answers.

  • Self-report and "mixed" EQ questionnaires ask people to rate themselves ("I stay calm under pressure"). Many popular commercial EQ tools are this kind.

What does the research say about ability EI?

A major meta-analysis by Joseph and Newman (2010) proposed a "cascading model": perceiving emotions comes first, then understanding them, then regulating them, which then feeds job performance. They wrote that "the cascading model of EI is empirically confirmed via meta-analytic data," but also that "relationships between ability-based EI and job performance are shown to be inconsistent" (Joseph & Newman, 2010, abstract).

The useful part for sales is when it worked. Ability EI predicted performance positively in jobs high in emotional labour, where managing your own and others' emotions is part of the work, and negatively in jobs low in emotional labour (Joseph & Newman, 2010). Customer-facing sales roles usually sit on the high side.

What about the self-report EQ questionnaires?

This is where the evidence gets uncomfortable for vendors.

Joseph, Jin, Newman and O'Boyle (2015) found that mixed EI measures correlated .29 with supervisor-rated performance. That sounds good. But once they controlled for ability EI, self-efficacy, self-rated performance, conscientiousness, emotional stability, extraversion and general mental ability, the unique contribution dropped to essentially nothing (Joseph et al., 2015). The content of those questionnaires overlapped heavily with things you can already measure.

Not everyone agrees. An earlier meta-analysis by O'Boyle and colleagues (2011) found all three streams of EI, including self-report and mixed measures, related to job performance, with corrected correlations of about .24 to .30, and that the self-report and mixed streams added some value beyond personality and cognitive ability (as cited in AlDosiry et al., 2016). A 2022 meta-analysis also found EI linked to job performance (about .30), job satisfaction (.29) and organizational commitment (.26) (Doğru, 2022).

Our read: EI measures relate to good outcomes, but a self-report EQ score adds little once you've already looked at a candidate's personality, confidence and ability.

What about leadership?

EQ is often sold for hiring sales managers. Harms and Credé (2010) found a strong link between EI and transformational leadership (.59) when the same source rated both, but only about .12 when ratings came from different sources. The authors put much of the gap down to common method bias, and most of the studies relied on self-reports for both (Harms & Credé, 2010). So be careful with any study where leaders rate their own EQ and their own leadership.

Where does EQ testing sit in Ontario?

Many EQ questionnaires assess personality-type traits. The Ontario Human Rights Commission's guidance says tests that assess "psychological or personality profiles" of applicants "should never be administered before a conditional offer of employment, and even then should be approached with caution" (Ontario Human Rights Commission [OHRC], 2008, section IV-6). Ability EI tests aren't personality questionnaires, but they're still psychometric tests, so we treat them the same way. In our own process, personality testing comes after the offer, and we use it for coaching and onboarding, not to decide who gets hired. Our cognitive and other ability testing comes after the offer too. Confirm your approach with employment counsel.

How to assess emotional skill in a sales hire

  1. Look for the behaviour, not the score. In a role play, give the buyer a worry they don't say out loud. Does the candidate notice and ask? Our post on how to run a sales role-play interview shows how to build that in.

  2. Ask about a hard emotional moment. "Tell me about a deal where the buyer got angry or went silent. What did you notice, and what did you do?" Look for specifics.

  3. Listen for whether they listen. Emotional skill in sales shows up as listening first. See interview answers that show a salesperson listens.

  4. If you buy any EI tool, ask which kind it is. Ability-based or self-report? What independent studies show it predicts performance in sales roles, after controlling for personality? Vendor-only evidence isn't enough.

  5. Keep every EI tool for after the offer. For personality-type tools, that's what Ontario's Human Rights Commission advises (OHRC, 2008). Ability-based EI tests are psychometric tests too, and in our process they wait for the offer as well.

Two things that are both true

We'll own one for HR: EQ became popular in our field partly because it made "soft skills" sound measurable. A lot of what got sold as measurement was a self-rating with a nice report.

Emotional skill really does matter in sales, especially in emotionally demanding selling. And most EQ questionnaires don't tell you much you couldn't learn from a good interview, a realistic role play and a candid reference. For owners in Guelph and across Ontario, watch the behaviour first.

In short

Ability-based emotional intelligence predicted performance positively in jobs high in emotional labour, like many sales roles (Joseph & Newman, 2010). Self-report and mixed EQ questionnaires correlated .29 with supervisor ratings but added essentially nothing once personality, self-efficacy and cognitive ability were controlled (Joseph et al., 2015), though other meta-analyses find modest added value (O'Boyle et al., 2011, as cited in AlDosiry et al., 2016). In Ontario, personality-type tests shouldn't be given before a conditional offer (OHRC, 2008), and in our process every EI test, ability-based included, comes after the offer. Before the offer, assess emotional skill through role plays, specific past-behaviour questions and references.

Key takeaways

  • Ability EI predicted performance positively in high emotional labour jobs and negatively in low emotional labour jobs (Joseph & Newman, 2010).

  • Mixed EI measures correlated .29 with supervisor-rated performance but added essentially nothing after controlling for personality, self-efficacy and cognitive ability (Joseph et al., 2015).

  • Another meta-analysis found corrected correlations of about .24 to .30 between EI streams and job performance (O'Boyle et al., 2011, as cited in AlDosiry et al., 2016).

  • The EI and leadership link fell from .59 to about .12 when ratings came from different sources (Harms & Credé, 2010).

  • Ontario's Human Rights Commission says personality-type tests should never be given before a conditional offer (OHRC, 2008).

Frequently asked questions

Do emotional intelligence tests predict sales performance?

Ability-based EI tests predicted performance positively in jobs with high emotional labour (Joseph & Newman, 2010), which describes many sales roles. Self-report EQ questionnaires mostly overlap with personality and confidence measures (Joseph et al., 2015).

What's the difference between ability EI and self-report EQ?

Ability EI tests have right and wrong answers to emotional problems. Self-report EQ questionnaires ask people to rate themselves. The research supports ability measures more for predicting performance.

Can I use an EQ test before making a job offer in Ontario?

Many EQ tools assess personality-type traits, and the Ontario Human Rights Commission says those tests should never be given before a conditional offer of employment (OHRC, 2008). Ability-based EI tests work differently but are still psychometric tests, and in our own process all psychometric testing comes after the offer. This is general information, not legal advice; confirm with employment counsel.

What should I ask an EQ test vendor?

Ask whether the test is ability-based or self-report, and for independent studies showing it predicts sales performance after accounting for personality and cognitive ability.

Work with us

Down to your last few candidates? Our Final Candidate Review tests your finalists against your own best people before you make the offer. If it doesn't help, you don't pay.

This post is general information, not legal advice. Confirm employment decisions with employment counsel.

References

Previous
Previous

How to Attract Passive Candidates for a VP of Sales Search

Next
Next

Sales Manager or VP of Sales: Which Should You Hire First?